Warble Get the app

Warble / Guides / Apps and how they work

The best bird song identifier apps, compared honestly

Four apps will tell you what is singing outside. They are built for different people. Here is what each one does, what it costs, and which to install first.

Updated · 7 min read · by the Warble team

If you want one free app that names birds by sound and by photo, install Merlin Bird ID from the Cornell Lab. It is the reference tool, it works offline, and it costs nothing. BirdNET is the research app behind much of the field, also free, and sends your recording to a server. The Audubon Bird Guide is a field guide with eight hours of songs and calls, not a listener. Warble is different in kind: a collecting game built around live sound identification, free for one catch a day, iPhone only, US birds only, offline.

The four apps at a glance

AppPriceIdentifies byWorks offlineWhat it is for
Merlin Bird ID (Cornell Lab)FreeSound, photo, or a few questionsYes, Sound ID and downloaded bird packsThe all-purpose identifier and reference
BirdNET (Cornell Lab and Chemnitz University)FreeSound, from a recording you make in the appRecording yes, identification no: audio goes to a serverResearch app; your submissions feed science
Audubon Bird GuideFreeField marks you pick (color, size, shape), plus browsingYes, once the guide packet is downloadedA field guide with photos, range maps and sounds
WarbleFree, one catch a day; Pro $3.99 a week or $19.99 a yearSound, live, compared on the phone against 800 US speciesYes, after a one-time download of about 100 MBA collecting game: cards, state albums, rarities

One caution before the details. Every one of these apps makes suggestions, and Merlin's own help page says it plainly: the app offers possible matches, and you decide whether the match is good by listening to the sample recordings. A loud road or wind on the microphone will confuse any of them.

Merlin Bird ID: the one to install first

Merlin is made by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology and it is free on iPhone and Android. It identifies in three ways. You can answer a few questions about size, colors and what the bird was doing and get a short list of likely species for your location and date. You can upload a photo, a feature added in 2017. Or you can open Sound ID, tap record, and watch names appear in real time as birds sing, with sample recordings you can play to compare. Sound ID covers more than 2,000 species by sound, including most birds of the United States, Canada and Europe, and it can pick out several species singing at the same time.

It works offline. Cornell's help pages say Sound ID runs no matter how far you are from cell service, and that it does not even need a bird pack downloaded; the packs add photos and species information for a region so you can read about the bird once it is named. As of 2025 the app has about 10 million users. If you are going to have one bird app, this is it, and it costs nothing.

BirdNET: the research app

BirdNET comes from the K. Lisa Yang Center for Conservation Bioacoustics at the Cornell Lab and Chemnitz University of Technology in Germany. It is free, it launched on Android in 2018 and on iOS in 2020, and it is the engine behind a lot of the bird-sound science of the last few years. You record in the app, and the recording, along with the date, time and location, is sent to the BirdNET server, which returns the likely species. The 2022 paper describing the project reports more than a million users and 31 million submissions in 2020 alone, and the current model recognizes more than 3,000 species worldwide.

That design has consequences. The server needs a connection, so on a trail with no signal you can record and save clips but the answer arrives later. The upside is that every submission you make becomes an anonymized data point that researchers use to study migration timing and how song dialects spread. If you like the idea that your morning walk contributes to science, BirdNET is the app for you. If you want an instant answer with no network, it is not.

Audubon Bird Guide: the field guide

The Audubon Bird Guide does not listen. It is a free field guide that covers more than 800 North American species with over 3,000 photos, multi-season range maps and more than eight hours of recorded songs and calls. You identify a bird by filtering on what you saw: location, date, color, size, tail and wing shape. It also keeps a life list, shows nearby hotspots and recent sightings from eBird, and lets you download the guide packet for use offline.

Where it earns a place next to Merlin is afterward. Once an app has given you a name, the Audubon guide is where you read up on the bird and play its call next to its song. It is the book you would have carried twenty years ago, with the audio built in.

Warble: the game

Warble is a different kind of app, and it is fair to say so up front: it is not trying to be a better Merlin. It is a collecting game built around live sound identification. You tap the green button, the phone listens, and when a bird is named it becomes a card. Cards fill an album of 100 birds for each state, and rarity comes from real sighting data, so a Northern Cardinal in Ohio is a common card and a Varied Thrush in Ohio is a prize. The catalog is 800 US birds, and the app compares the sound on the phone against them, so it works with no signal after a one-time download of about 100 MB.

It is free to play with one catch a day. Pro removes the limit and costs $3.99 a week or $19.99 a year. It is iPhone only and US only, it identifies by sound only, and like every app on this page it can be unsure when the yard is loud. The reason to play it is not accuracy; it is that a daily catch and a half-finished album make you go outside and listen.

A first session in most of the country catches birds like these, all common cards in most state albums:

Which one should you get?

  • You want to know what that bird is, right now, for free. Merlin. Nothing else on this list is as complete, and Sound ID works offline.
  • You want your recordings to help research. BirdNET. Expect to need a connection for the answer.
  • You want to read about the bird after you name it. The Audubon Bird Guide, with Merlin doing the naming.
  • You want a reason to go outside every morning. Warble. Keep Merlin on the phone too; the two do different jobs.

The honest recommendation is Merlin plus whichever of the others matches the way you enjoy birds. All four are free to try.

Get Warble free

Questions people ask

Is Merlin Bird ID really free?

Yes. Merlin is free on iPhone and Android, with no subscription. It is funded and built by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, and Sound ID, Photo ID and the offline bird packs are all included.

What is the difference between Merlin and BirdNET?

Both come from the Cornell Lab. Merlin is a general identifier that runs Sound ID on the phone, works offline and also identifies by photo. BirdNET is a research project with Chemnitz University; its app sends your recording to a server and each submission becomes anonymized research data.

Does any bird song app work without cell service?

Merlin's Sound ID works offline according to Cornell's help pages. Warble identifies on the phone after a one-time download of about 100 MB. BirdNET needs a connection for the identification itself, though you can record and save clips offline.

Is Warble more accurate than Merlin?

Warble does not make that claim. Merlin is the reference tool and is free. Warble's difference is the game around identification: cards, state albums of 100 birds, and rarities drawn from real sighting data, with one free catch a day.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Merlin Bird ID. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merlin_Bird_ID
  2. Cornell Lab Help Center: Merlin Sound ID. support.ebird.org/en/support/solutions/articles/48001185783-sound-id
  3. Wood et al. 2022, PLOS Biology: The machine learning-powered BirdNET app reduces barriers to global bird research. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9239458
  4. BirdWatching: BirdNET app is a game-changer for bird research. www.birdwatchingdaily.com/birds/field-guides-and-apps/birdnet-app-bird-research/
  5. App Store: Audubon Bird Guide. apps.apple.com/us/app/audubon-bird-guide/id333227386

Warble is a game, not a field guide. Where this page states a fact about a bird, it comes from the sources above.